Baca artikel IDN Research Institute lainnya di IDN App
It helps you see more of our articles when you search on Google
Gen Z Rarely Looking Something New Anymore: 5 Signs of Their Nostalgia
ilustasi membeli piringan hitam (pexels.com/AndreaPiacquadio)
  • Gen Z is turning back to pocket cameras, physical books, vinyl records, and secondhand clothing, weighing their usefulness, durability, meaning, and relevance to life today.

  • Economic pressure is driving more selective consumption: 59% of Gen Z practice frugal living, while thrifting appeals for its price, uniqueness, resale value, and environmental awareness.

  • The comeback of older categories gains momentum when they appear in new contexts and shape identity and community; the preloved market has become a competitor to fashion brands.

This section summary was AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

In today's fast-paced digital era, novelty arrives almost without pause. New trends surface on social media, shift within days, and are replaced by the next one. Amid this constant churn, one phenomenon stands out: Gen Z, the generation with the greatest access to everything new, is also showing a growing interest in goods and experiences from the past.

Old-school pocket cameras are back in demand. Vinyl records are finding new listeners. Secondhand clothing has become part of everyday consumption choices. Physical books still hold their ground amid the dominance of screens.

This phenomenon is often read simply as nostalgia. That factor is certainly present, but something more interesting emerges when we look closely at how young people actually choose. Old items don't come back just because they're from the past. They come back when they still offer something that feels relevant to consumers' lives today.

This shift is also visible in how young people view consumption itself. According to a statement by Adian Napitupulu, Deputy Chair of the People's Aspiration Agency (Badan Aspirasi Masyarakat/BAM) at the Indonesian House of Representatives, made during a meeting with Commission VI of the DPR in November 2025, around 67% of millennials and Gen Z choose thrifting as a form of environmental awareness. Napitupulu noted that a single pair of jeans requires about 3,781 liters of water, while a single cotton t-shirt requires 2,700 liters — equivalent to 2.5 years' worth of human drinking water. Awareness that the textile industry contributes to 20% of global air pollution is one of the drivers behind the growing interest in secondhand goods.

The real question, then, isn't simply why Gen Z likes old things. The more interesting question is: what makes something from the past feel relevant to today's consumer again?

Why Is Gen Z Turning Back to the Past?

Several shifts in the context of Gen Z's lives help explain this phenomenon. They have broad access to trends, yet at the same time face economic pressures and life choices that make every consumption decision need to feel sensible.

1. Digital Fatigue and the Search for Meaning

Gen Z has access to far more choices than previous generations. Indonesians spend an average of 21 hours and 50 minutes per week on social media, spread across 7.7 platforms each month (We Are Social & Meltwater, 2025).

That volume of information makes novelty extremely easy to find. But being easy to find doesn't always mean being worth owning. Amid so many trends, consumers still need to determine which ones fit their needs, means, and the way they want to live their lives.

This shift aligns with findings from the Indonesia Millennial & Gen Z Report (IMGR) 2027 by IDN Research Institute. Young people are redefining success. Success is no longer measured solely by owning a house or a car, but by four pillars: meaning in life, financial breathing room, flexibility, and adaptability (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026).

This shift in how success is viewed is also changing how consumption itself is judged. Benefit, durability, and meaning are becoming increasingly important in determining whether a product or experience deserves a place in their lives (IDN Research Institute, 2026).

In this context, something old still has a chance. As long as it offers value that matches today's needs, a product's age doesn't automatically make it irrelevant.

2. Economic Pressure and New Consumption Behavior

Economic conditions make this filtering process even more important. Indonesia's market structure is undergoing a significant shift. Currently, around 50.4% of the population falls into the "aspiring middle class" bracket (IDN Research Institute, 2026).

At the same time, young people are developing new ways to manage spending. An IDN Research Institute survey shows that 59% of Gen Z have adopted frugal living as a financial management strategy amid economic challenges (GoodStats, 2025).

Frugal living doesn't mean consumption stops altogether. What changes is how people decide what's worth buying. Price, benefit, durability, and a product's meaning all become part of a bigger consideration.

This is where older categories can find new room. Secondhand goods, pocket cameras, physical books, and vinyl records each have different characteristics, but all of them can offer a form of value that consumers are still looking for.

3. Different Priorities: Gen Z vs. Millennials

This filtering process also relates to what people consider important in life. A survey by IDN Research Institute and Populix shows a difference in priorities between Gen Z and millennials.

35% of Gen Z rank career as their top priority, compared to 30% of millennials. Meanwhile, personal development ranks higher among Gen Z at 14%, versus 7% among millennials (Databoks, 2025).

These figures provide important context: Gen Z's consumption takes place within a strong orientation toward self-development and the future. Because of this, a product has a greater chance of gaining traction when it can be placed within the life story they are building for themselves.

From here, we can identify five signals that help us read when an old category has a chance to find a new audience.

5 Signals of Relevance: How to Read a Comeback Trend

An old category can regain attention when the context around it changes. The same product can carry a different social and cultural function when used by a different generation.

The following five signals help illustrate that shift.

1. New Context

The first signal appears when an old product shows up in a context that was previously unimaginable.

Old-school pocket cameras, for instance, were once seen as fading technology. Now they're being hunted down at Pasar Baru in Jakarta, local flea markets, and online thrift listings (Radar Madiun, 2026).

This change in context gives the product's old characteristics new meaning. A camera once used simply because it was the available technology is now sought after for the distinctive character of its visual results.

Something similar is happening with physical books. IDN Research Institute's IMGR 2026 report shows that 41% of Indonesian Gen Z still read physical books regularly, and 58% say they read for self-development and to broaden their knowledge (Gramedia, 2026).

Amid the dominance of digital content, physical objects still hold a place when the experience they offer matches what consumers need.

2. New Narratives from Consumers

New context then gives rise to new ways of talking about a product.

Photos from old digicams, for example, are now read through a different visual vocabulary. Color saturation, artistic grain and noise effects, and the distinctive flash glow have become part of what's known as "Y2K aesthetics" (Radar Madiun, 2026).

Traits once seen as technological limitations are now part of the product's appeal.

This shift matters because consumers aren't just buying an object. They're also buying into a visual language, an experience, and a story attached to that object.

When consumers start attaching new vocabulary to an old product, that category gains a chance to live within a new cultural context.

3. A Marker of Identity

Vintage products can then evolve from mere objects into markers of identity.

IDN Research Institute notes that consumption is shifting toward products or experiences seen as meaningful and value-adding (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026). Spending on concerts, merchandise, and creator content is viewed not merely as consumption, but as part of identity and social participation (IDN Research Institute, 2026).

The same principle can help explain why old products can gain new appeal. When an object can say something about a person's taste, community, or self-image, its value goes beyond its original function.

Because of this, a pocket camera or a vintage garment can become part of how someone presents themselves — just like a brand-new product.

4. Economic Value Meets Cultural Value

There are also situations where economic and cultural considerations intersect in a single purchasing decision.

The ThredUp Resale Report 2026 found that 60% of consumers now consider resale value an important factor when buying new clothing, up from 47% the year before (ThredUp & GlobalData, 2026).

This means consumers can view a product through more than one lens. Purchase price is one consideration, but potential use, resale value, and the meaning attached to a product also shape its perceived worth.

At this point, "old" doesn't always mean "less valuable." In certain conditions, an item's age, rarity, or character can become part of the value consumers are looking for.

5. Communities Form Around the Category

The final signal is the emergence of community.

Communities become the place where a category's knowledge, standards, and rituals are learned and passed on. According to IDN Research Institute, activity within community ecosystems such as the fan economy and creator economy continues to grow, even as young people shop more cautiously (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026).

Communities can also offer something brand communication alone struggles to create: context.

Within a community, consumers learn what to look for, how a product is used, what's considered authentic, and why a category deserves a second look.

So when an old category starts forming a new community around it, what's growing isn't just demand for the product itself — the knowledge and culture surrounding it are growing too.

Economic and Social Impact

When these five signals appear together, a category's comeback can grow into a broader shift in consumption behavior.

Thrifting is one of the clearest examples of this. It brings together economic need, the search for identity, a preference for uniqueness, and the formation of community.

The Scale of the Thrifting Market

According to data from the Ministry of Cooperatives and SMEs presented at a Commission VI DPR meeting, there are 900,000 secondhand clothing businesses in Indonesia, with nearly 7.5 to 10 million people depending on this trade for their livelihood (Bisnis.com, 2025).

Consumer interest is also reflected in various surveys. A GoodStats survey (2022) found that 49.4% of Indonesians have thrifted before, while a TinkerLust survey (2022) recorded that 42% of Indonesians enjoy buying secondhand clothing.

These figures show that secondhand clothing already holds a place in society's consumption habits. What's interesting is how this category keeps gaining new meaning as it enters young people's consumption culture.

A Threat to Fashion Brands

This shift carries direct implications for the fashion industry. IDN Research Institute notes that the preloved (secondhand goods) market has become a new competitor to fashion brands.

The competition doesn't stop at price. The preloved market offers a different combination of value: access to lower-priced goods, the chance to find unique items, and the use-value and stories that can attach themselves to an item.

Because of this, brands with a strategy for the preloved market — whether through trade-in programs, buy-back schemes, or refurbished product lines — have room to remain relevant amid this shift.

Economic Anxiety as a Driver of Adaptation

Behind this shift in consumption behavior lies a broader economic context. A survey by IDN Research Institute and Populix found that 55% of respondents identified economic instability as their main source of anxiety (Databoks, 2024).

Yet this pressure is also tied to young people's capacity to adapt. IDN Research Institute notes that economic pressure is pushing young people to become more resilient. They are learning to manage their finances, seek additional income, and build more adaptive lives (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026).

From a consumption standpoint, this adaptability shows up in how consumers search for alternatives. When needs remain constant but resources must be managed more carefully, categories once seen as outdated can re-enter the picture.

Marketing Intelligence Strategy for Marketers

This shift opens up a more interesting question for marketers. When consumers start breathing new life into old categories, opportunity doesn't always lie with the newest product.

There are old values that may still be relevant — they just need a new context to become visible again.

1. Audit the Brand Archive

A brand's past can be a source of insight.

Design archives, old usage rituals, origin stories, and products that once had a specific user base can all be revisited to uncover value that still resonates.

The question isn't simply which old product could be relaunched. The more important question is: what value from the past is still relevant to today's consumer?

2. Focus on Value and Meaning

IDN Research Institute emphasizes that young people are becoming more selective in their spending, focusing on long-term value, benefit, and relevance (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026).

Because of this, a product needs a clear reason to earn a place in consumers' lives. Price is part of the equation, but benefit and meaning determine whether a product feels worth holding onto.

For marketers, this means reading consumption through a combination of functional value and cultural value.

3. Anticipate Competition from the Preloved Market

The preloved market is expanding the definition of competition within the fashion industry. IDN Research Institute notes that brands competing on price alone will be up against a secondhand market that is structurally cheaper.

Room for differentiation can then be built through durability and long-term use-value.

When consumers start thinking of a product as something that can be used longer, traded, resold, or passed down, product quality becomes part of the value proposition itself.

4. Tap into Community Ecosystems

Communities can serve as an entry point for understanding how a category gains new meaning.

Even as young people shop more selectively, activity within community ecosystems continues to grow (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026). Partnering with communities can provide both credibility and access to core consumers.

Beyond that, communities can help brands understand the language, rituals, and standards that have already developed around a category. This is where marketing intelligence can move beyond simply reading trends toward understanding how those trends acquire their relevance in the first place.

Conclusion: What's Coming Back Is Relevance

Gen Z lives amid an abundance of exposure alongside limited resources. They encounter an ever-growing number of choices, then filter them based on what feels sensible given their needs, economic conditions, identity, and cultural context.

In that process, something from the past can get a second chance. Pocket cameras find a new aesthetic. Physical books still offer a relevant experience. Secondhand clothing becomes part of everyday consumption choices. Vintage products can become markers of identity. Communities then help all of that value grow into a new culture.

IDN Research Institute's IMGR 2027 report shows that this generation has already adapted ahead of the curve. They are learning to manage resources, develop themselves, and build a future amid constant change (FORTUNE Indonesia, 2026).

For brands, media, institutions, and policymakers, this shift opens up space to understand new ways young people learn, work, choose, and build their futures.

As Adian Napitupulu put it during the DPR meeting, thrifting cannot be viewed simplistically. It isn't just about low prices — it carries ecological awareness, identity, and relevance within it.

Ultimately, a category's comeback doesn't always mean repeating the past in the same form. Some old values find new function, context, and audience.

What comes back isn't always the past itself. What comes back is its relevance.

References

ANTARA News. (2025, November 19). Pemerintah diminta cari solusi soal "thrifting" sebelum menindak. https://www.antaranews.com

Bisnis.com. (2025, November 21). Adian Napitupulu Kritik Kebijakan Purbaya Cs Tertibkan Thrifting. https://ekonomi.bisnis.com

Databoks. (2024, December 3). Mayoritas Gen Z dan Milenial RI Dapat Rumah dari Warisan Keluarga. https://databoks.katadata.co.id

Databoks. (2024, December 4). Ini Genre Podcast Favorit Gen Z dan Milenial Indonesia. https://databoks.katadata.co.id

Databoks. (2025). Perbedaan Prioritas Gen Z dan Milenial. https://databoks.katadata.co.id

FORTUNE Indonesia. (2026, June 16). Takut Turun Kelas Ekonomi, Milenial dan Gen Z Justru Makin Tangguh. https://www.fortuneidn.com

GoodStats. (2025, March 5). Frugal Living: Strategi Cerdas Gen Z Kelola Finansial. https://data.goodstats.id

Gramedia. (2026, June 19). Buku Fisik Kembali Jadi Tren di Tengah Era Digital? Ini Faktanya!. https://www.gramedia.id

IDN Research Institute. (2026). Indonesia Millennial & Gen Z Report 2027: Adaptation as Strategy.

IDN Research Institute. (2026). Indonesia's Preloved Market and Changing Consumer Trends. https://www.idnresearchinstitute.com

Kompas.com. (2025, November 20). Curhat Pedagang Thrifting di DPR: Sudah Digempur Barang China, Masih Kena Razia. https://nasional.kompas.com

Radar Madiun. (2026, May 16). Demam Digicam Enthusiast: Kamera Saku Jadul yang Dulu Dianggap Sampah Elektronik, Kini Harganya Melejit. https://radarmadiun.jawapos.com

Suara Merdeka. (2025, November 20). Bukan Sekadar Murah: 67 Persen Milenial dan Gen Z Pilih Thrifting, Selamatkan 3.781 Liter Air Bersih!. https://www.suaramerdeka.com

ThredUp & GlobalData. (2026). 2026 Resale Report (14th ed.). https://ir.thredup.com/news-releases

We Are Social & Meltwater. (2025, November). Digital 2026: Indonesia. https://datareportal.com

Curated For You

Editorial Team

Related Article