Baca artikel IDN Research Institute lainnya di IDN App
Install

Consumers Want to Be Healthy, but Don’t Want to Feel Like a Project

16 min read
Consumers Want to Be Healthy, but Don’t Want to Feel Like a Project
The depiction of a healthy lifestyle (pexels.com/SHVETS production)
  • A PwC survey found that 59% of Indonesian respondents aim to live longer and healthier lives, yet 73% struggle to stay motivated; limited time, income, and convenience hinder consistency.

  • A Food Policy study found that the cheapest healthy diet is theoretically affordable for more than 98% of the population, yet actual diets remain low in fruit, vegetables, and legumes and high in discretionary foods.

  • Ease of use is a key consideration in choosing health products for 79% of respondents; the article highlights the importance of wellness benefits that blend into existing routines rather than adding the burden of new habits.

This section summary was AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

PwC’s 2026 Voice of the Consumer survey found that 59% of Indonesian respondents rank living longer and healthier among their top three health goals. Yet 73% admit they find it hard to stay motivated to achieve it.

The desire to live healthily is already there. The harder part is turning it into a habit.

Today, health covers many things: nutrition, exercise, sleep quality, supplements, and even wearables that help monitor the body’s condition. But knowing what is good for your health does not automatically make you able to do it consistently. Time, budget, and practicality still shape everyday choices.

This is where the wellness paradox emerges. Consumers want to live healthier, but not necessarily to take on so much extra work to get there. For brands, the question is not only how to make consumers interested in a healthy lifestyle, but how to deliver health benefits without requiring them to change their entire routine.

  1. Health Aspirations Exist, but Do Not Necessarily Become Habits

    Indonesian consumers’ desire to live healthily is not limited to physical appearance. Citing PwC Indonesia (2026a), of 503 respondents, 59% rank living longer and healthier among their top three health goals. Another 51% want to reduce stress or improve mental health, 41% prioritize self-development, and 28% want to lose weight or improve body composition.

    Attention to health is also visible in daily activities. Some 72% of respondents often plan and prepare meals at home, 59% take vitamins, minerals, or supplements, and 58% exercise regularly.

    Technology plays a part too. Some 86% often use health apps or wearables for at least one health activity, while 71% say they would ask AI first when they have a health question.

    However, these figures measure different things. Health goals, self-reported habits, and intentions to use technology cannot be treated as equivalent. A stated intention to ask AI, for example, does not yet show actual behavior. Likewise, an activity described as frequent is not necessarily carried out consistently every week.

    The gap shows up in activities that require ongoing planning. Only 37% of respondents regularly monitor and improve their sleep patterns, while 28% actively plan their eating patterns or nutritional intake.

    PwC’s data was collected through an external panel provider between February and March 2026. These figures describe the survey respondents and do not automatically represent the entire Indonesian population.

    Even so, the broad picture is clear enough: attention to health is visible in many forms, but that attention does not necessarily turn into a sustained routine.

  2. Wanting to Be Healthy, or Wanting to Be a Healthy Person?

    Another dimension helps explain why consumers are drawn to wellness: health is not only about physical benefits, but also about identity.

    A qualitative study by Djaja and Candraningrum (2026) of Gen Z students in a fitness community at Tarumanagara University found that a healthy lifestyle is understood as a symbol of discipline, mental balance, and social presence. Respondents’ initial motivation was often linked to appearance and exposure to fitness content on social media, before developing into values shared within the community.

    Over time, healthy habits can become attached to the way people see themselves. One respondent even admitted to feeling strange when not exercising.

    Findings on the consumption side paint a similar picture. A quantitative study by Purnama Sari and Putri (2025) of 220 Gen Z respondents in Bali who actively live a healthy lifestyle found that the fit between a lifestyle and personal identity had a significant effect on impulsive and compulsive buying within the research model. By contrast, the perceived superiority of health benefits showed no significant effect.

    Together, these two studies suggest that identity may be related to consumption decisions. However, buying a product that matches one’s self-image does not necessarily mean the person will use it regularly. The Bali study also did not measure continued use of the products purchased.

    The scope of this research is limited to students at one campus in Jakarta and to Gen Z consumers in Bali who already live actively healthy lifestyles. The findings cannot be directly generalized to all of Gen Z, let alone all Indonesian consumers.

    For IDN Research Institute, these findings raise a hypothesis: identity may attract consumers at the outset, but it is not necessarily enough to sustain a habit. Once health has become part of everyday life, a product’s value may also be determined by how easily its benefits can be felt.

  3. The Wellness Gap: Not Just a Matter of Price

    So what makes the desire to live healthily hard to realize?

    Of the 484 respondents who answered the question about challenges in achieving health goals in PwC Indonesia’s (2026a) survey, 73% cited difficulty staying motivated, 67% a lack of time, and 50% limited disposable income beyond basic needs.

    These are three different barriers. Motivation relates to the sustainability of behavior, time limits the activities that can be done, and income affects the choices available. Discounts may help with price constraints, but they do not automatically provide time to exercise or prepare meals. Digital reminders, too, are not necessarily enough to sustain motivation.

    Consumers’ considerations when choosing health products show that price is not the only factor they weigh. Ease of use was the most frequently chosen criterion (79%), followed by value for money (77%), personalization to individual needs (65%), and price (64%).

    Interest in support for building habits is also evident. Some 56% of respondents are interested in coaching and behavior-change programs. However, this interest is not evidence that they already follow such programs or are willing to pay for them. For comparison, PwC Indonesia’s (2026b) press release states that only 12% of consumers regularly take part in community-based wellness activities.

    Meanwhile, only 35% of respondents regularly set a dedicated budget for health activities. This figure measures budgeting habits, not financial capacity. Not setting a dedicated budget does not mean a person cannot afford health products or services.

    Thus, the wellness gap cannot be explained solely by high or low interest in health. There is another issue: how easily can consumers turn healthy choices into reality amid the constraints of daily life?

  4. If a Healthy Diet Is Affordable, Why Aren’t Diets Healthy?

    A study by Costlow et al. (2026) in the journal Food Policy helps clarify this issue through the context of food consumption in Indonesia.

    The researchers matched BPS retail prices with consumption data from the March 2023 Susenas covering 341,802 households. They then calculated the cost of the cheapest healthy diet that meets national dietary guidelines, based on foods available in the nearest market.

    The result: the average cost of the cheapest healthy diet was around Rp10,710 per day for the requirements of one adult woman. According to the researchers’ calculations, household food expenditure is theoretically sufficient to afford this diet for more than 98% of the population. About 1.9% of the population have food expenditure below the required cost.

    However, theoretical affordability is not reflected in actual diets.

    Discretionary foods, such as sugar, sweets, and salty snacks, contribute 15% of daily energy. This is more than three times the portion tolerated by the guidelines, which is about 4%. Consumption of fruit, vegetables, legumes, and whole grains is also still insufficient across all income groups. On average, diets meet only 42% of food group recommendations and 45% of nutrient requirements.

    Income differences do matter, but they do not fully explain the gap. Households in the highest income quintile meet about 45% of food group recommendations, only slightly above the lowest quintile, at about 40%. Higher-income groups also consume more discretionary foods and mixed dishes.

    Vegetables offer a more concrete example. Households in the poorest quintile spend an average of about Rp1,300 per day on vegetables, while the cheapest vegetables needed to meet the recommendation would cost only about Rp675. Although the average spending is higher than the cheapest option, vegetable consumption remains inadequate.

    This means that greater spending does not automatically produce consumption patterns that match recommendations.

    The researchers suspect that food choices are also shaped by the food environment, including culinary traditions, practicality, the time and cost of preparing food, and preferences influenced by advertising, marketing, and labels. These factors are the researchers’ interpretation, not variables directly tested by the study.

    These findings also have limits. The calculation uses the cheapest locally available foods, not products marketed with health labels. The theoretical ability to afford a diet differs from the ease of finding, preparing, and sustaining that diet. The results do not automatically apply to skincare, supplements, wearables, or health services.

    Affordability is also uneven across regions. In Papua, about 20% of households cannot afford the cheapest healthy diet, and in some areas the figure reaches 45%. The study’s data comes from 2023, three years before the PwC survey.

    So price still matters. For some households, purchasing power is a real barrier. But even when healthy choices are theoretically affordable, they do not necessarily become part of everyday consumption patterns.

    This is what makes the wellness paradox more complex than a matter of price. Consumers need not only choices they can afford, but also choices that fit easily into their lives.

  5. From Wellness as Identity to Wellness as Infrastructure

    These findings point to a strategic hypothesis from IDN Research Institute: the value of a wellness product should be viewed not only through the identity it offers, but also through the ease it provides.

    Wellness as Identity

    Wellness as Infrastructure

    I am a healthy person

    This fits my life

    Identity

    Routine

    Discipline

    Convenience

    Restriction

    Substitution

    Effort

    Ease

    Health as lifestyle

    Health embedded in lifestyle

    In the first approach, the product offers an image of who its user is. Consumers are expected to sustain behavior consistent with that identity through discipline and personal effort. Yet when 73% of respondents admit they struggle to stay motivated, an approach that relies heavily on individual consistency faces real obstacles.

    The second approach treats ease as part of product design. With 79% of respondents choosing ease of use as one of the main criteria for health products and 67% saying they lack time, products that fit existing schedules and habits have the potential to reduce the extra effort consumers must put in.

    This difference is also visible in eating patterns. Susenas data processed by Costlow et al. (2026) show that rice dominates staple foods across income groups, while tempeh and tofu contribute most of the energy from the legume group.

    Asking consumers to abandon familiar eating patterns can add barriers. Improving choices within patterns people already follow offers a different approach: not only asking consumers to avoid certain foods, but making better alternatives easier to choose.

    The study of the fitness community at Tarumanagara University also suggests that identity and practical support can complement each other. Respondents described how their motivation to exercise could decline when training alone, while the community helped them motivate one another (Djaja & Candraningrum, 2026).

    In other words, identity can be a reason to start, while environment and ease can help sustain the habit.

    This framework is a strategic interpretive lens developed by IDN Research Institute from a synthesis of several sources, not an empirically validated model. The PwC survey also does not prove a causal relationship between the two approaches.

    Nevertheless, the framework gives brands a question they can test: which parts of the consumer experience need to be made easier so that health benefits are easier to realize?

  6. Reduce Health Friction

    If ease is one source of value in wellness products, brands need to recognize the barriers that arise in different usage contexts. In this article, health friction refers to things that make a healthy choice feel like extra work.

    FMCG: Improve the Choices Already Being Bought

    In FMCG products, taste and habit are important considerations. Costlow et al. (2026) note that consumption of discretionary foods dominated by sugar and sweets was found across all income groups. Healthier options must compete with products consumers already know and like.

    Brands can test gradual reformulation, smaller portion options, or ingredient substitution in products that are already bought routinely. This approach allows change without always asking consumers to change their shopping habits.

    Two things to check are whether reformulated variants are repurchased at rates comparable to the original variants, and whether changes in taste lead consumers to add sugar or other portions when consuming the product at home.

    Food & Beverage: Healthy Without Alienating Taste

    In the food and beverage category, healthy options need to remain consistent with consumers’ tastes and eating habits. Data from Costlow et al. (2026) show that mixed dishes, including rice and noodle preparations, contribute a large share of energy across income groups. Legume consumption also remains low, even though tempeh and tofu are the main sources of energy from that food group.

    One approach that can be tested is to increase the portion of vegetables, tempeh, or tofu in familiar menu items. These ingredients can become part of the standard offering, not only a special menu for consumers who are on a diet.

    Brands need to observe whether modified menu items continue to be reordered and whether the added ingredients replace part of other portions or instead increase total calories. Repurchase alone is not enough to confirm that menu changes lead to healthier consumption patterns.

    Beauty & Health: Reduce the Burden of Remembering

    Preventive care can feel like an extra chore when consumers must remember many steps, understand a wide range of claims, and sort through conflicting information.

    According to PwC Indonesia (2026a), 59% of respondents take supplements and 35% use apps to remind them of their medication or supplement schedules. At the same time, 42% feel overwhelmed by too much or conflicting health information.

    Brands can consider ways to link product use to existing routines, such as breakfast or a nighttime skincare routine. Simple usage instructions can help reduce the burden of remembering additional steps. This approach needs to be accompanied by clear, accountable benefit claims. Some 78% of respondents expect clear information about products and how they work.

    Indicators that can be monitored include usage rates after 30, 60, and 90 days and the proportion of consumers who buy refills. These metrics can show sustained use, although they do not prove the health outcomes achieved.

    Digital Health: From Tracking to Action

    Health apps and wearables can collect a great deal of data, but that data does not necessarily help users decide on their next step.

    Some 71% of respondents say they would ask AI first when they have a health question. However, only about 20% place AI conversations or devices among the five strongest influences on their health actions. Friends and family (56%) and healthcare professionals (57%) have greater influence (PwC Indonesia, 2026a; 2026b).

    This difference matters for digital product development. Having answers easily available does not automatically lead someone to change their behavior.

    Product value can be developed through a sequence of tracking, understanding, guidance, and then action: collecting data, helping users understand it, providing relevant direction, and supporting steps they can actually take.

    Some 77% of the 434 app or wearable users are willing to pay more for devices whose data can be reviewed by healthcare professionals. This finding shows interest in professional support in using health data, although reported willingness to pay does not necessarily translate into actual transactions.

    To evaluate their products, brands can monitor the proportion of users who follow app recommendations, the stage at which they stop opening the app, and the rate at which notifications are turned off. These measurements help show whether the technology becomes part of a routine or instead adds to users’ burden.

    Does the Product Ask Consumers to Change Their Habits?

    Consumers have many reasons to live healthier. However, sustaining those habits requires time and effort that are not always available. In the PwC Indonesia survey, 73% of respondents struggle to stay motivated and 67% lack time.

    For brands, the question to ask is not only whether the product offers health benefits, but also: does our product ask consumers to change their habits, or can it be used within the habits they already have?

    Repeat purchase and frequency of use can be early signals for answering this. The two need to be read together. Repeat purchase without information on frequency of use does not explain whether the product has truly become part of a routine. Conversely, regular use may indicate that a product has found its place in daily life, but it does not necessarily guarantee that consumers will buy it again.

    For digital services and subscription programs, brands also need to record when users stop using the service or stop purchasing.

    These metrics help measure adoption and sustained use; they do not prove behavior change or improvements in consumers’ health. Claims about health outcomes still require their own measurement methods.

    Ultimately, the wellness paradox is not simply about consumers who want to be healthy but find it hard to be consistent. There is a distance between knowing what is good, being able to choose it, and sustaining it as a habit.

    The brand opportunity lies in narrowing that distance: not by continually adding demands in the name of health, but by delivering benefits that are easier to live with in everyday life.

    References

    Costlow, L., Gilbert, R., Masters, W. A., Ortenzi, F., Beal, T., Deo, A., Sutiyo, W., Noor, S., & Gonzalez, W. (2026). Healthy diets are affordable but often displaced by other foods in Indonesia. Food Policy, 140, Article 103076. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodpol.2026.103076

    Djaja, C. A., & Candraningrum, D. A. (2026). Konstruksi sosial healthy lifestyle dalam budaya fitness Gen Z di lingkungan perguruan tinggi [The social construction of a healthy lifestyle in Gen Z fitness culture in a university setting]. Koneksi, 10(1), 134–145. https://journal.untar.ac.id/index.php/koneksi/article/download/37139/22690/113557

    Purnama Sari, D. M. F., & Putri, N. K. D. K. (2025). Perilaku pembelian tak terkendali pada healthy lifestyle Generasi Z: Mengeksplorasi peran moderasi self-control [Uncontrolled buying behavior in Generation Z’s healthy lifestyle: Exploring the moderating role of self-control]. Journal Research of Management, 7(1), 34–47. https://doi.org/10.51713/jarma.2025.7161

    PwC Indonesia. (2026a). Voice of the Consumer 2026 survey: Indonesia survey result [Report]. https://www.pwc.com/id/en/publications/consumer-markets/pwc-voice-of-the-consumer-2026-indonesia.pdf

    PwC Indonesia. (2026b, September 3). Masyarakat Indonesia semakin mengandalkan teknologi, sumber terpercaya dan komunitas dalam menjalani gaya hidup yang lebih sehat, menurut survei PwC [Indonesians increasingly rely on technology, trusted sources, and community in pursuing healthier lifestyles, according to PwC survey] [Press release]. https://www.pwc.com/id/en/media-centre/press-release/2026/indonesian/voice-of-the-consumer-survey-2026.html

Related Articles

See More