Baca artikel IDN Research Institute lainnya di IDN App
Install

56% of Consumers Are Meal Planning: Is Impulse Buying Still Relevant?

16 min read
56% of Consumers Are Meal Planning: Is Impulse Buying Still Relevant?
A girl planning on budget (pexels.com/Antoni Shkraba)
  • Cost-of-living pressures are driving 56% of Indonesian consumers to plan their meals and 63% to switch to cheaper alternatives, so shopping decisions are increasingly formed before consumers enter the store.

  • Consumers control their spending by monitoring basket value, comparing channels, and limiting the brands they buy in certain categories, even as the variety of their cooking-ingredient needs remains intact.

  • Promotions still influence brand choice, particularly for routine needs; FMCG brands need to be relevant from the planning stage, available across channels, and adjust their bundling and packaging accordingly.

This section summary was AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

Cost-of-living pressures are beginning to change how Indonesian consumers determine their food needs. PwC’s 2025 Voice of the Consumer Survey found that 56% of Indonesian respondents plan to plan their meals earlier to curb impulse spending, while 63% plan to switch to cheaper alternatives (PwC Indonesia, 2025b).

For FMCG brands, the 56% figure indicates that food purchase decisions are increasingly considered before consumers enter the store. Meal planning does not merely help households organize their menus and budgets; it also determines which products make it onto the needs list, which categories are prioritized, and how much budget is allocated to each purchase. This means brand competition no longer takes place only on the store shelf. Brands also need to be present when consumers begin compiling their needs and making their choices.

Meal planning does not lock in every shopping decision. Consumers still choose the brand, pack size, channel, and timing of their purchases. However, when needs are planned earlier, the room for brands to influence decisions changes as well. Promotions, product availability, and the relevance of an offer need to work from the consideration stage, not only when consumers face the product in the store.

Drawing on data from PwC, NielsenIQ (NIQ), Worldpanel by Numerator, and the Access to Nutrition initiative (ATNi), this article examines how meal planning relates to changes in spending management, brand choice, purchase rhythm, and responses to promotions. These changes offer a picture of how FMCG brands need to adjust their strategies to remain part of consumers’ routine needs.

  1. Meal Planning as a Strategy for Controlling Spending

    The 56% figure emerges against a backdrop of economic concern that is higher than the regional average. Half of Indonesian respondents (50%) cited economic instability and the cost of living as the greatest threat over the next 12 months, higher than in Asia Pacific (42%) and globally (44%). PwC positions plans to buy cheaper alternatives and to plan meals as two consumer responses to these concerns (PwC Indonesia, 2025b). The survey was conducted from January to February 2025 among 21,075 consumers in 28 countries and territories, including Indonesia (PwC Indonesia, 2025a).

    The two responses work through different mechanisms. Buying cheaper alternatives reduces the price per item, whereas planning meals helps consumers manage how their spending is allocated. Before entering the store, they can determine what they need, how much to prepare, and when to buy it. Some purchase decisions are therefore made earlier, when menus and shopping lists are drawn up at home. For brands, this stage is a critical point for building relevance before consumers face a choice of products.

    In a separate question about eating habits, PwC recorded the proportion of respondents who plan their meals earlier at 26% among Gen Z, 32% among millennials, and 35% among Gen X (PwC Indonesia, 2025b). These figures show that meal planning is practiced across all generational groups, with a higher proportion among Gen X than among Gen Z.

    The same generational data also reveals variation in how consumers control their spending. Gen X plans meals most often (35%) and also buys fresh ingredients most often (51%), with 35% choosing economy brands. Gen Z, meanwhile, has a lower proportion of meal planners (26%), yet 36% choose economy brands. For marketers, this difference suggests that cost-saving strategies need to consider more than age alone. How consumers organize their needs and choose products can be just as important in understanding their response to cost-of-living pressures.

    PwC’s press release also states that economic concerns are prompting consumers to buy less and to choose cheaper alternatives (PwC Indonesia, 2025a). These two responses indicate the direction that spending control takes: consumers can reduce expenditure by limiting their purchases while also managing the composition of the products that go into their basket. NIQ’s shopping behavior data shows how these saving strategies are reflected in everyday purchase decisions.

  2. From Spontaneous Purchases to Basket Management

    NIQ data shows that Indonesian consumers control their FMCG spending down to the basket level, not merely through the price of each product. In the Mid-Year Consumer Outlook 2024, the top two saving strategies were each chosen by 46% of respondents: monitoring the overall cost of their shopping basket and shopping online to get better deals. Next were switching to cheaper options (38%), ceasing to buy certain products to focus on essentials (37%), and shopping more often at discount or lower-priced stores (36%) (NielsenIQ, 2024).

    The ordering of these strategies shows that saving happens through several decisions at once. Consumers monitor total cost, compare offers, switch stores, and adjust their product choices. On average, each shopper applies 4.9 strategies simultaneously (NielsenIQ, 2024). This means price competition at the individual product level is only one part of the consideration. The overall value of the basket also becomes an important yardstick when consumers decide what to buy.

    Another finding from NIQ’s consumer panel data reveals a more interesting pattern. The repertoire of cooking-ingredient categories that households buy is actually widening. The proportion of households buying more than five cooking-ingredient categories rose from 47.3% in 2022 to 49.8% in 2024. In several categories, however, the number of brands purchased is moving in the opposite direction. The proportion of households buying fewer than two cooking oil brands rose from 16.8% to 28.9%, while for noodles it increased from 22.0% to 24.3% (NielsenIQ, 2024).

    These two trends point to a change that matters for FMCG brands: households maintain the diversity of their category needs but increasingly limit their brand choices in certain products. In other words, consumers are not necessarily reducing the types of needs they must fulfill. Rather, they are increasingly consolidating the brands they choose to meet those needs. NIQ reads the narrowing of brand repertoires as one way consumers keep spending under control, among other things by reducing the number of brands and taking advantage of promotions.

    For brands, the implication is not only how to sustain demand for a category, but how to sustain their position within the household’s choice set. When category needs remain diverse while the number of brands purchased narrows, competition for repeat purchases becomes increasingly important. Brands that are squeezed out risk losing their place in the shopping routine, even though the product category is still needed.

  3. Does Planning Change Shopping Formats and Frequency?

    Each retail format carries a different shopping rhythm. Citing ATNi (2025), minimarkets serve smaller, more frequent purchases; supermarkets are generally visited weekly, with mid-week restocking; and traditional retail serves daily purchases with a “buy today, eat today” approach, driven in part by financial constraints.

    This rhythm is related to the types of products bought through each channel. Modern retail accounted for only 24.1% of daily-necessities retail sales in 2024, yet it controls roughly 63% of packaged food sales, according to a 2021 analysis summarized by ATNi. Conversely, traditional markets absorb more than 95% of spending on tofu, fish, and poultry, as well as most vegetables and fruit (ATNi, 2025). Given this pattern, fulfilling a single household meal plan may involve several channels at once: fresh ingredients from traditional markets and FMCG products from minimarkets or supermarkets. FMCG brands need to take into account that their products are part of a shopping pattern spread across multiple channels.

    Several indications suggest that shopping in modern retail is moving toward consolidation. ATNi, citing McKinsey data, notes that the average basket size in modern retail has increased while visit frequency has declined (ATNi, 2025). Worldpanel reported a similar pattern in the first quarter of 2026: FMCG growth was driven mainly by higher volume per transaction, while price per unit weakened. Lower socioeconomic groups drove growth through larger baskets, whereas upper groups did so through more frequent shopping trips (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026a).

    These findings show that FMCG growth is not always built through the same purchasing mechanism. Some households increase the number of products in a single transaction, while other groups increase the frequency of their visits. Ramadan is also an important context for reading the first-quarter 2026 data, as Worldpanel noted that the period remained a spending driver amid economic pressure (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026a). For brands, these differing patterns need to be translated into distribution and packaging strategies: formats that support stock-up shopping for one group of consumers, and packs suited to replenishment for another.

    Consumers also do not rely on a single channel. Worldpanel found that Indonesian consumers visit an average of three to four channels per month, and nearly 40% of households now buy FMCG online (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026b). Channel switching has become one of the saving strategies: 46% of NIQ respondents shop online to get better deals, while 36% shop more often at discount or lower-priced stores (NielsenIQ, 2024).

    Large planned purchases and small, high-frequency purchases can therefore coexist. The pattern of supermarkets being visited weekly and then topped up mid-week shows how consumers meet their needs through stock-up shopping and then complete their supplies at minimarkets when necessary. For distribution, product availability at both moments is important. A product that is present only in the main shopping channel can miss purchase opportunities when consumers replenish in another channel.

  4. When Planned Needs Meet Promotions

    Shopping plans do not eliminate the role of promotions. On the contrary, when consumers have defined their needs earlier, price offers can become one of the factors that determine which brand is ultimately chosen.

    NIQ consumer panel data shows that the share of purchases made because of promotions increased across all eleven categories displayed between 2022 and 2024. The largest increases occurred in staple categories: cooking oil rose from 22% to 39%, sweetened condensed milk from 15% to 29%, and liquid milk from 14% to 23% (NielsenIQ, 2024).

    This pattern matters because cooking oil and milk are among the categories that can form part of a routine shopping list. The increased share of promotion-driven purchases indicates that price offers play a growing role in purchase decisions in these categories. In terms of attitude, 29% of NIQ respondents said they buy whichever brand is offering a promotion (NielsenIQ, 2024). For consumers who already plan to buy cooking oil, a promotion can be a consideration in determining the brand or the timing of the purchase.

    Promotions can also work in a different direction. ATNi notes that middle- and upper-class consumers in modern retail often make impulse purchases influenced by in-store promotions and perceptions of product quality. ATNi also cites evidence that bulk-purchase discounts and buy-one-get-one-free offers can encourage overconsumption (ATNi, 2025). The effect depends on the promotional mechanism: price cuts on products already on the shopping list can help consumers reduce costs, while volume-based promotions have the potential to push purchases beyond planned needs.

    The composition of promotions in modern retail shows which categories receive substantial space in the offers. ATNi’s analysis of promotional materials from Alfamart, Indomaret, and Super Indo found that sweet foods and ice cream made up 24.0% of promoted items at Indomaret and 18.2% at Alfamart. Sweetened beverages accounted for 17.2% at Alfamart and 13.0% at Indomaret, while processed grains, bread, and snacks accounted for 26.3% at Indomaret (ATNi, 2025). The Alfamart data was taken from its e-commerce promotions page. This composition shows which categories are heavily offered through modern retail promotions.

    For categories that are not always routine needs, promotions play a different role. Snacks, sweet foods, and sweetened beverages can compete for a share of spending beyond core needs. As consumers pay closer attention to their shopping lists and total spending, brands in these categories need to craft offers relevant enough to be considered. Meanwhile, staple categories can use promotions to strengthen brand choice in repeat purchases.

    For this reason, promotional effectiveness cannot be measured by transaction volume spikes alone. Worldpanel advises brands to optimize promotional support while driving shopper recruitment and retention, especially in minimarkets, where promotions play an important role (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026b). For consumers who plan their shopping, a promotion needs to give them a reason to choose a brand and to keep buying it in subsequent transactions. A promotion’s success does not end with accelerating transactions; it also lies in its ability to build repeat purchases.

  5. What Do FMCG Brands Need to Change?

    The common thread running through the findings above is that meal planning brings purchase decisions to an earlier stage. Consumers no longer decide on products only when they are in the store; they begin organizing menus, needs, and spending allocations before shopping. At the same time, NIQ and Worldpanel data show that spending control also takes place through category composition, the number of brands, channels, transaction size, and responses to promotions.

    For FMCG brands, this change calls for a strategy that is not oriented solely toward increasing the number of products in a single transaction. Brands need to ensure that their products are relevant to needs that have already been planned, easy to find in the channels consumers use, and offer value strong enough to be chosen again. There are three strategic areas to consider.

    Bundling. Bundling is relevant for consumers who already have a list of needs, with one condition: the contents of the bundle must reflect those needs. NIQ data shows that 49.8% of households buy more than five cooking-ingredient categories, such as cooking oil, soy sauce, stock, spices, chili sauce, and margarine (NielsenIQ, 2024). This diversity of categories purchased by households opens opportunities to develop menu-based bundles that help consumers meet several needs at once. Bundles that merely increase the number of units risk falling into the territory of volume promotions, which ATNi links to overconsumption. The test is simple: does the bundle help consumers fulfill their shopping list at a lower cost, or does it add products they do not need?

    Pack format and size. Worldpanel emphasizes the importance of pack sizes and formats that suit the needs of different demographic groups, as well as price architecture that can adapt to shoppers’ circumstances (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026b). First-quarter 2026 findings provide additional context: lower socioeconomic groups drove growth through larger baskets, whereas upper groups did so through increased shopping frequency (Worldpanel by Numerator, 2026a). These differing patterns can serve as the basis for developing two packaging needs: formats suited to stock-up shopping and smaller formats for replenishment at minimarkets. For consumers who monitor total basket cost, the price-per-unit difference between the two formats also needs attention so that the smaller pack still offers reasonable value.

    Promotions. Promotions need to be directed at adding value to needs that consumers have already defined, not merely at creating additional purchases. In routine categories such as cooking oil, promotions can help brands compete for a place within consumers’ increasingly limited choices. A brand that is successfully chosen stands a chance of retaining the next purchase. The timing and channel of promotions also need to be taken into account. If some decisions are already made when the shopping list is drawn up, promotions visible only in the store aisle risk reaching consumers too late. Online channels, which 46% of NIQ respondents use to find better deals, can be a space to reach consumers from the search and planning stage.

    Category implications. Cooking oil, sweetened condensed milk, and liquid milk recorded large increases in the share of promotion-driven purchases, while cooking oil also showed a narrowing of brand repertoires. In these categories, competition takes place among the brands being considered to fulfill routine needs. Meanwhile, snacks, sweet foods, and sweetened beverages feature heavily in minimarket promotional materials. These categories face a different challenge: brands need to build relevance so that their products earn a place in consumers’ spending allocation. This distinction can serve as a basis for brands to determine the role of promotions, pack formats, and distribution strategy according to category characteristics.

  6. Meal Planning and the New Direction of FMCG Competition

    Meal planning is one signal that consumers are increasingly actively managing their spending before they shop. PwC data shows that this intention emerges as a response to cost-of-living pressures. NIQ and Worldpanel data complete the picture through patterns of basket management, the narrowing of brand choice in certain categories, channel switching, and the growing role of promotions in purchase decisions.

    Taken together, these findings show that FMCG competition is increasingly determined by a brand’s ability to become part of the needs that consumers have already planned. When households maintain category diversity but limit the number of brands they buy, sustaining category demand alone is not enough. Brands must also hold their place in the household’s choice set and ensure their products are available when those needs are fulfilled.

    The strategic question for marketers is no longer simply how much volume has been built through promotions and bundling, but how much of that volume generates repeat purchases. Growth that comes from products entering the routine shopping list rests on a different foundation than growth that depends solely on short-lived promotional pushes. This distinction matters when brands evaluate the effectiveness of promotions, packaging development, and distribution investment.

    Looking ahead, one thing to watch is whether the increase in volume per transaction recorded by Worldpanel in the first quarter of 2026 will hold in quarters without festive moments. If the pattern continues, shopping consolidation could become an increasingly important characteristic in FMCG strategy, especially for the development of stock-up packs, need-based bundling, and product availability in main channels. Conversely, if volume per transaction weakens and shopping frequency rises again, replenishment strategies, more flexible packaging, and cross-channel distribution will become increasingly decisive.

    Under either scenario, the ability to read how consumers plan their meals, organize their needs, and choose products will form the basis for brands to maintain their relevance. Meal planning is not merely a change in how consumers put together their menus. For the FMCG industry, this practice shows how purchase decisions are increasingly formed before the transaction takes place, so the competition to win a place in the shopping basket also begins earlier.

    References

    Access to Nutrition initiative. (2025). Indonesia retail assessment 2025: Country report. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://accesstonutrition.org/app/uploads/2025/11/20251127_Indonesia_Retail_Assessment_Country_Report_1.pdf

    NielsenIQ. (2024). Indonesia’s consumer outlook: A guide to 2025. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://nielseniq.com/global/en/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2024/11/indonesia-mid-year-consumer-outlook-guide-to-2025.pdf

    PwC Indonesia. (2025a, July 8). Ketidakstabilan ekonomi dan tekanan biaya hidup pengaruhi keputusan dan prioritas konsumen Indonesia, menurut survei Voice of the Consumer 2025 dari PwC [Economic instability and cost-of-living pressures influence Indonesian consumers’ decisions and priorities, according to PwC’s Voice of the Consumer 2025 survey] [Press release]. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://www.pwc.com/id/en/media-centre/press-release/2025/indonesian/ketidakstabilan-ekonomi-dan-tekanan-biaya-hidup-pengaruhi-keputusan-dan-prioritas-konsumen-indonesia-menurut-survei-voice-of-the-consumer-2025-dari-pwc.html

    PwC Indonesia. (2025b). PwC’s Voice of the Consumer 2025: Indonesian consumer key takeaways [Infographic]. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://www.pwc.com/id/en/consumer-industrial-products-services/voice-of-the-consumer-2025-indonesia.pdf

    Worldpanel by Numerator. (2026a, June 11). Indonesia FMCG Monitor Q1 2026. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://worldpanelbynumerator.com/insights/indonesia-fmcg-monitor-q1-2026

    Worldpanel by Numerator. (2026b, June 8). Shoppers’ quest for value and inspiration is reshaping Indonesian FMCG. Retrieved November 2, 2026, from https://worldpanelbynumerator.com/insights/indonesia-fmcg-outlook-2026

Related Articles

See More