Baca artikel IDN Research Institute lainnya di IDN App
It helps you see more of our articles when you search on Google
Transparansi dan keterbukaan informasi mendukung pengawasan publik. (Pexels)
  • Survei PwC 2026 menunjukkan 88% konsumen Indonesia menilai kepercayaan setara dengan harga dan kualitas, sementara 81% bersedia pindah merek demi transparansi lebih besar.

  • Konsumen makin aktif memverifikasi klaim melalui AI, tenaga kesehatan, ulasan, dan lingkungan terdekat; mereka menuntut informasi produk, biaya, serta pengalaman transaksi yang jelas dan konsisten.

  • Keamanan data, perlindungan dari penipuan, dan akuntabilitas perusahaan turut membentuk kepercayaan; janji pemasaran perlu didukung bukti terverifikasi, kualitas nyata, dan respons transparan.

This section summary was AI-assisted and reviewed by our editorial team.

Before purchasing a product, consumers may go through multiple sources of information: reading product labels, watching creator reviews, checking comment sections, and comparing marketplace ratings. They are not simply looking for the best product. They are gathering evidence to make sure their purchasing decisions are the right ones.

This shift has made trust an increasingly strategic factor in consumer decision-making. PwC’s Voice of the Consumer 2026 survey found that 88% of 503 Indonesian respondents consider trust in a brand just as important as price and quality. More notably, 81% said they would be willing to switch to another brand that offers greater transparency.

Conducted between February and March 2026, the survey focused on consumer behavior and spending related to health and wellness. In this category, trust is no longer merely an added value. It now stands alongside two of the key considerations that have traditionally shaped consumer choices: price and quality.

Yet, an interesting paradox has emerged. Access to information has expanded, but consumers are not necessarily becoming more confident. Product claims are everywhere, recommendations come from multiple directions, and technology allows anyone to get answers within seconds. In this environment, determining which information deserves to be trusted has become increasingly difficult.

For brands, the challenge is no longer simply about capturing consumer attention. The more fundamental question is how to earn consumers’ trust, especially when they have more reasons than ever to scrutinize every claim.

More Information, Greater Challenges in Building Trust

Modern consumers face an information paradox: the more information available, the more effort it takes to filter through it.

In the same PwC survey, 42% of respondents admitted feeling overwhelmed by the abundance of health information or conflicting information. This situation is particularly relevant in the health category, where claims about product benefits, ingredients, and how products work are widespread.

When information does not immediately translate into confidence, consumers seek additional layers of verification. PwC found that 71% of respondents would turn to AI first when seeking answers to health-related questions. AI is becoming an initial point of reference for information searches, but that does not mean every answer it generates is automatically trusted.

In the report, PwC Indonesia Advisor Sasanka Dutta cautioned that not all online information is accurate. Retailers, brands, and healthcare providers therefore have a role to play in helping consumers identify misinformation, scams, and inaccurate benefit claims.

Consumer expectations are also quite clear. A total of 78% of PwC respondents expect clear information about products and how they work. In other words, consumers are not satisfied with promises of benefits alone. They want to understand what they are buying, how the product works, and what they can realistically expect from it.

The need for clarity does not end with product information. The transaction experience itself also plays a role in building trust.

According to a press release from the Ministry of Trade (Kemendag), the ministry received 7,887 consumer service reports throughout 2025, consisting of 7,526 complaints, 258 inquiries, and 103 information reports. As many as 7,836 of these reports were related to transactions conducted through electronic trading systems.

In the electronics and motor vehicle sectors, complaints frequently involved products that did not match sellers’ promises, damaged goods, and warranty claim issues.

Meanwhile, the Indonesian Consumers Foundation (YLKI) received 133 online shopping complaints throughout 2025, as reported by Kontan.

These figures bring the issue to a more tangible level. Trust is not built solely when consumers read product descriptions. It is also shaped by whether the products they receive match the information, quality, and promises made by sellers.

Kemendag also interprets the increase in the value of disputed transactions as a sign that consumers are becoming more willing to speak up for their rights.

Cost transparency is another part of this experience. In digital transactions, the price displayed upfront does not necessarily reflect the total amount consumers eventually have to pay. YLKI recommends strengthening digital consumer literacy to reduce the risks of dark patterns and purchases driven by fear of missing out (FOMO).

A legal study by Hasir and Fransisca (2026) identifies four indicators of cost transparency in electronic transactions: completeness of cost information, timing of disclosure, clarity of the total payment, and consumer consent based on adequate information.

For brands, the implications are clear: the greater consumers’ need to verify information, the less room there is for communication that relies solely on appeal. Product information, prices, additional fees, and service terms need to be communicated openly from the outset.

A good brand does not simply convince consumers before a transaction. It also ensures that no unpleasant surprises await them afterward.

Who Do Consumers Trust for Information?

As information becomes easier to find, the next question is: who do consumers trust to explain it?

In the digital ecosystem, consumers encounter multiple sources simultaneously: brands, creators, fellow buyers, experts, family members, friends, and AI-powered answer engines. Each comes with a different level of familiarity and credibility.

The PwC survey offers a picture of the information sources that influence consumers in the context of health. When asked what motivates them to pursue their health goals, respondents most frequently cited personal curiosity (59%), healthcare professionals (57%), and family and friends (56%).

Media content accounted for 45%, wellness trends for 34%, and influencers for 27%.

This breakdown shows that influencers are indeed one source of information, but they are not consumers’ only point of reference. In health-related categories, personal experience, professional recommendations, and close social circles continue to play important roles.

So, what makes a creator trustworthy?

A study by Naufaijlal and Widyatama (2026), published in Mediakom: Jurnal Ilmu Komunikasi, surveyed 492 Generation Z TikTok users aged 18–26 in the Special Region of Yogyakarta. The research examined trust in influencers as a source of communication.

The findings showed that influencer authenticity (β = 0.369) and parasocial relationships—the sense of closeness audiences develop with the creators they follow (β = 0.441)—were both positively associated with trust.

Together, these two factors explained 55.2% of the variation in trust. Authenticity contributed a unique 7.3%, while parasocial relationships contributed 10.4%. The remaining 37.5% was explained by the combined contribution of both factors.

Interestingly, the bootstrap test in the study found that the difference between the two coefficients was not statistically significant. This suggests that authenticity and perceived closeness are both important components in building audience trust.

These findings offer an interesting perspective for influencer marketing strategies. Consumers do not simply pay attention to who is speaking, but also to how their relationship with the creator has developed. A sense of closeness and perceived authenticity can make messages easier to accept.

However, one distinction matters: trust in a creator does not automatically translate into trust in every product they promote.

Popularity and familiarity can capture audience attention, but the credibility of an endorsement still depends on whether the recommendation aligns with the audience’s own experience and judgment.

The same applies to consumer reviews and user-generated content. Ratings, transaction volumes, and photo reviews serve as social proof—signals that other people have made a purchase and shared their experiences.

However, the strength of these signals depends on the authenticity of the reviews. High ratings lose their meaning when consumers are no longer certain that the experiences being shared actually come from buyers.

Ultimately, digital trust is not built through a single information source. Consumers may like a creator, find high ratings, and still seek confirmation through other buyers’ reviews or sources they consider authoritative.

This cross-checking process makes consistency increasingly important. If a brand’s message differs from buyers’ experiences, or a creator’s recommendation does not match the product’s quality, consumers have more sources than ever to identify the discrepancy.

In an interconnected information ecosystem, one source may spark interest. But consistency across multiple sources is what makes trust last.

Trust Also Means Feeling Safe

There is another aspect that often goes unnoticed in marketing communications but plays a significant role in the consumer-brand relationship: the feeling of safety.

In PwC’s survey, which focused on health and wellness, 63% of respondents said they expect strong privacy and data protection from products or services.

This expectation is increasingly relevant as more consumer activities take place through digital platforms. From information searches and transactions to personalized recommendations, these interactions involve personal data.

Government monitoring data indicate that data protection remains an issue that requires attention.

According to detikInet, the Directorate General of Digital Space Supervision at the Ministry of Communication and Digital Affairs (Komdigi) recorded 342 complaints through its personal data protection (PDP) service between October 2024 and November 2025. Of these, 41% were related to personal data protection issues.

Komdigi also monitored 350 digital platforms and identified potential violations in 41% of the website sample (115 out of 280) and 34% of the application sample (24 out of 70).

During the same period, Komdigi recorded 56 suspected PDP violations, with spikes in June 2025, accounting for 20 cases, and July 2025, with 15 cases.

By the end of 2025, the Draft Government Regulation on Personal Data Protection had reached its final stage, while the draft Presidential Regulation on the PDP agency was still undergoing harmonization.

Digital risks, however, extend beyond the collection and use of personal data. Consumers also need to feel safe when making transactions.

According to an OJK press release, the Indonesia Anti-Scam Centre (IASC) received 432,637 scam complaints between November 22, 2024, and January 14, 2026, with total reported losses reaching Rp9.1 trillion.

Online shopping scams were among the reported schemes. This situation highlights the importance of being cautious of parties impersonating official institutions or companies. OJK, for example, has urged the public to be wary of websites claiming to represent IASC.

In the context of marketing, these security concerns have implications that go beyond regulatory compliance.

Personalization, for instance, can make consumer experiences feel more relevant because recommendations are tailored to their behavioral data. However, relevance has its limits when consumers do not know what data is being used or feel they have lost control over their personal information.

For this reason, a brand’s ability to explain how data is collected, used, and protected has become part of the product experience itself.

Brands can no longer rely solely on offering personalization that feels relevant. Consumers also need to understand what happens behind that experience.

The more personalized a service becomes, the more important it is to be transparent about how that personalization works.

When Consumer Trust Is Tested by Brand Accountability

Consumer trust is not limited to product quality and transaction experiences. Corporate decisions and behavior can also influence how consumers perceive a brand.

In consumer behavior studies, this phenomenon is associated with ethical consumption and political consumerism, in which social and political values become part of purchasing considerations.

Boycotts are one expression of this behavior. Sunandi and Garnida (2026) noted that boycott sentiment related to global sociopolitical issues has strengthened in Indonesia since late 2023.

But how does information about boycotts influence consumer decisions?

A study by Sari et al. in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, published in March 2026, examined the role of social media in this process.

The online survey involved 328 young consumers aged 18–25 who had participated in boycotts and accessed boycott-related news on social media. Data collection began in January 2025, focusing on food brands targeted by boycotts.

The findings revealed two distinct pathways through which information influences consumers.

Emotional framing was strongly associated with trust in information on social media and had a direct effect on boycott intention. Factual framing, on the other hand, was more closely associated with the formation of negative brand image, without a significant direct effect on boycott intention.

Trust in social media information also played a role in shaping brand image. Its relationship was reflected in both negative perceptions of targeted brands and positive perceptions of local brands. These perceptions were subsequently associated with consumers’ intention to purchase local brands as alternatives.

In other words, the way an issue is communicated can shape consumer responses, from rejecting a particular brand to considering alternative products.

However, boycott intentions do not always translate into the same changes in purchasing behavior.

Another study by Sunandi and Garnida (2026), published in the International Journal of Economic, Business, Accounting, Agriculture Management and Sharia Administration (IJEBAS), offers a different perspective.

The study surveyed 300 Indonesian biscuit consumers who were familiar with one multinational brand and one local brand, followed by 10 in-depth interviews. The majority of respondents (79%) were aged 25–34, while 55% lived in Greater Jakarta (Jabodetabek).

The findings showed that boycott sentiment had a negative and statistically significant, albeit relatively weak, effect on brand trust, brand preference, and purchase intention. Boycott sentiment explained 2.1% of the variation in brand trust.

In contrast, brand trust had a strong effect on preference, while preference was the strongest factor influencing purchase intention.

The in-depth interviews helped explain why consumer attitudes do not always result in a decision to stop buying a product.

Participants expressed genuine humanitarian concerns, but their purchasing decisions still took product experience into account. Accumulated trust, taste, familiarity, and household habits remained part of their considerations.

Local alternatives were also considered, although they were rarely chosen as full replacements.

These two studies offer complementary perspectives. The first examines young consumers who had actively participated in boycotts, while the second looks at regular buyers within a specific product category.

Both show that moral attitudes, brand trust, loyalty, and purchase intention are interconnected, but they do not necessarily influence one another with the same intensity.

For brands, this means negative sentiment on social media cannot be assessed solely by the volume of conversations or the intensity of boycott calls. Changes in perception need to be observed alongside shifts in preference and purchasing behavior.

Participants in the IJEBAS study also expressed expectations that are relevant to multinational brands: transparent and culturally sensitive corporate responses, backed by concrete actions and consistent product quality.

Communication is part of that response. However, corporate actions and product experiences also determine whether those responses are genuinely trusted.

A company’s statements can influence its reputation, but trust is also determined by what it does when its values and interests are put to the test.

From Brand Promises to Verifiable Evidence

When all these findings are viewed together, an interesting shift in consumer expectations emerges: consumers are no longer evaluating only what brands promise, but also how easily those promises can be verified.

This shift has at least four implications for brand strategy.

1. Product information must be easy to understand, not merely available.

As many as 78% of PwC respondents expect clear information about products and how they work in the context of health and wellness.

For brands, providing large amounts of information does not automatically address consumer needs. Information must be structured so that consumers can understand a product’s benefits, ingredients, mechanisms, and limitations without having to conduct additional investigations.

2. Marketing promises must match the actual product experience.

Products that do not match sellers’ promises were among the main complaints received by Kemendag in the electronics and motor vehicle sectors.

Participants in the IJEBAS study also emphasized the importance of product quality in supporting corporate communications.

This suggests that marketing effectiveness cannot be separated from operational consistency. A promise that successfully attracts buyers can become a source of reputational damage when the post-purchase experience fails to meet expectations.

3. Credibility matters more than popularity alone.

The influencer study showed that authenticity and parasocial relationships were both associated with audience trust.

Meanwhile, consumer reviews derive their value from the authenticity of the experiences being shared.

For marketers, this is a reason to reassess approaches that focus too heavily on reach and popularity. Source credibility, recommendation relevance, and consistency in consumer experiences should also be part of campaign evaluations.

4. Consumer protection is part of brand accountability.

As many as 63% of PwC respondents, in the context of health and wellness, expect strong data protection.

Meanwhile, studies on boycotts show that corporate reputation and behavior also factor into consumer considerations, although responses vary across groups.

Transparency in data usage, transaction security, and corporate responses to social issues are no longer merely supporting concerns. They are part of how consumers assess a brand’s accountability.

How Will Consumers Behave in 2027?

In 2027, consumer trust will increasingly depend on a brand’s ability to provide verifiable evidence, whether for product claims, communications, or business practices.

Brands will still need persuasive communication to build awareness and capture attention. However, the influence of such communication will increasingly depend on transparency, consistency, and accountable corporate practices.

When consumers can compare information from multiple sources, trust is no longer entirely in brands’ hands to shape through narratives. Consumers have more opportunities to test whether those narratives reflect reality.

What Should Brands Evaluate?

Ultimately, trust is tested through consumers’ everyday experiences, from product information to how companies respond when questions or problems arise.

There are two areas that can serve as starting points for brand evaluation:

  • Decision-making question: If one of your brand’s key claims were challenged publicly tomorrow, what evidence could you immediately present, and where could consumers access it?

  • Signals to monitor: The questions that frequently appear in review sections, comments, and customer service interactions, particularly those concerning ingredients, total costs, or data usage. Brands should also monitor how quickly they respond with clear and verifiable information.

Ultimately, consumers do not always need the brand that speaks the loudest. They need a brand that can explain what it offers, deliver on what it promises, and take responsibility for what it does.

Because when information becomes easier to find, having a reason to trust becomes an increasingly valuable differentiator.

References

Anastasia, C. (2026, January 14). YLKI terima 133 aduan konsumen belanja online, didominasi masalah di marketplace. Kontan. Accessed November 4, 2026, at https://industri.kontan.co.id/news/ylki-terima-133-aduan-konsumen-belanja-online-didominasi-masalah-di-marketplace

Hasir, M., & Fransisca, M. (2026). Transparansi biaya tambahan sebelum akad elektronik: Analisis hukum ekonomi syariah dan perlindungan konsumen di Indonesia. Jurnal Penelitian Ilmiah Multidisipliner, 3(02). https://doi.org/10.70294/q94nze78

Ministry of Trade of the Republic of Indonesia. (2026, January 12). Kemendag terima 7.887 laporan pengaduan konsumen pada 2025: 99 persen berhasil ditangani [Press release]. Accessed November 4, 2026, at https://www.kemendag.go.id/berita/siaran-pers/kemendag-terima-7887-laporan-pengaduan-konsumen-pada-2025-99-persen-berhasil-ditangani

Naufaijlal, R., & Widyatama, R. (2026). Autentisitas influencer, hubungan parasosial, dan kepercayaan Generasi Z terhadap influencer TikTok. Mediakom: Jurnal Ilmu Komunikasi, 10(1), 62–81. https://doi.org/10.35760/mkm.2026.v10i1.472

Financial Services Authority (OJK). (2026, January 21). Indonesia Anti-Scam Centre berhasil kembalikan Rp161 miliar dana masyarakat korban scam (SP 15/GKPB/OJK/I/2026) [Press release]. Accessed November 4, 2026, at https://ojk.go.id/id/berita-dan-kegiatan/siaran-pers/Pages/IASC-Berhasil-Kembalikan-Rp161-Miliar-Dana-Masyarakat-Korban-Scam.aspx

PwC Indonesia. (2026, September 3). Masyarakat Indonesia semakin mengandalkan teknologi, sumber terpercaya dan komunitas dalam menjalani gaya hidup yang lebih sehat, menurut survei PwC [Press release]. Accessed November 4, 2026, at https://www.pwc.com/id/en/media-centre/press-release/2026/indonesian/voice-of-the-consumer-survey-2026.html

Sari, A. (2025, December 28). Komdigi terima ratusan aduan soal perlindungan data pribadi. detikInet. Accessed November 4, 2026, at https://inet.detik.com/law-and-policy/d-8281251/komdigi-terima-ratusan-aduan-soal-perlindungan-data-pribadi

Sari, D. K., Games, D., Besra, E., Usman, N. A., & Triani, L. A. (2026). Emotion vs fact: The power of social media news framing in motivating young boycotters. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 13, Article 642. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-026-06987-6

Sunandi, S. D., & Garnida, N. (2026). From boycott to buycott: How sociopolitical crises shape brand trust, preference, and intention to purchase biscuit products in Indonesia. International Journal of Economic, Business, Accounting, Agriculture Management and Sharia Administration (IJEBAS), 6(4), 2083–2090. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21815483

Editorial Team

Related Article

Trending in English

See More